The true purpose of happy hour isn’t to discount your products but to audition potential regulars who will sustain your business for years to come.
Let’s be honest. Most pubs run happy hour to fill empty seats and make a few quid during slow periods. But what if we told you that getting folks through the door is just the beginning? The real gold lies in turning those one-time happy hour visitors into familiar faces.
Happy hour is your window of opportunity. Done right, it’s a system for growing loyalty, building community, and increasing long-term revenue. Think of every pint, G&T, or sharing platter as the start of a new relationship. That stranger at the bar could become your Friday regular for the next five years.
This isn’t rocket science, but it does require a plan. We’ll walk you through six priority steps to turn those bargain hunters into die-hard regulars. Each step builds on the previous one, creating a system that consistently converts casual happy hour drinkers into loyal guests who visit rain or shine, happy hour or not.
Step 1: Nail the First Experience, Make It Memorable
You never get a second chance at a first impression, especially during happy hour.
The first three minutes matter most. Why? Because that’s when people decide if they’ll come back. Happy hour might bring them in, but it’s the experience that brings them back.
So the way you greet, serve, and engage immediately shapes everything that follows. Happy hour or not, people remember how you made them feel.
Now, let’s break down what makes that first impression count:
Start with the basics, genuine greetings:
Make it personal, not robotic. Even if you’re busy, train your team to acknowledge every guest within seconds of arrival. A simple “Hey, welcome in! I’ll be right with you,” works wonders compared to the cold shoulder many busy bars give.
Keep your bar setup clean and efficient:
Menus should be easy to read, and surfaces should be spotless. Nothing says “we don’t care” like sticky surfaces and cluttered spaces. Your bar should look just as good at peak happy hour as it does when you open.
Make sure staff know the happy hour deal by heart and can explain it quickly:
Quick explainers make a difference. Train staff to give a 10-second rundown of the happy hour deal when they take first orders. “Our happy hour includes all draft beers and house wines. It runs until 7, and you can order as many as you like.” Simple but helpful.
And don’t hide in the back:
Owners or managers should be visible, walking the floor, making eye contact, offering a smile, and chatting with guests.
Owner’s Tip
Introduce yourself personally to at least three happy hour tables each night.
When guests feel seen, they feel valued. And before they even finish their first drink, it’s time to start planting the seed of return.
Step 2: Create a Reason to Return, Immediately!
Don’t let them leave without giving them a reason to return
The best time to secure a repeat visit is while they enjoy their first one. This is when they’re experiencing your venue at its best and most receptive to returning. If you don’t give them a reason to return soon, they’ll forget you by next week. Timing is everything.
Here are tactics that work:
Try Bounce-back offers:
Hand out simple cards that say, “Loved having you at happy hour! Come back tomorrow for 2-for-1 tapas between 5-7 pm.” or “Friday’s first round is on us.” These targeted offers create immediate opportunities for return visits.
Create some FOMO (fear of missing out) with limited offers:
Add exclusive happy hour dishes or drinks that change weekly.”We’re doing a special whiskey tasting for returning happy hour guests next Tuesday. Should I put your name down?” People hate missing exclusive experiences.
Track visits quietly through POS notes or loyalty systems and reward repeat guests:
Surprise guests with a free snack or shot if they mention they returned from last week’s happy hour. You may tell first-time happy hour guests, “Next time you visit, your first drink is on us.” It costs less than advertising and builds a genuine connection. Log it in your POS or use a simple visit tracking system to remember.
Happy hour “preview tastings” of upcoming menu items work brilliantly too. Let happy hour guests sample small tastes of a new cocktail joining your menu next week. They’ll want to come back to try the full version.
Owner’s Tip
Print mini cards or receipts with a bounce-back deal and hand them out as you thank guests on their way out.
Now that you’ve given them a reason to return, the goal is to stay on their radar between visits.
Step 3: Stay Present, Even When They’re Not in the Venue
If you’re out of sight, you’re out of mind. Fix that.
Out of sight, out of mind. The gap between visits is where most bars lose potential regulars. People are bombarded with options and distractions. They forget how much they enjoyed your place, or they simply fall back into their usual routines. Your job is to stay present in their world.
Here’s how to keep showing up:
Collecting contact info:
Collect email addresses or mobile numbers with a QR sign-up linked to a drink perk during happy hour. Place QR codes on happy hour menus that offer an immediate perk (like a free bar snack) in exchange for contact details. “Scan here for your complimentary truffle fries and happy hour updates.”.
Follow up personally within 24 hours:
Send a short, friendly thank-you message within 24 hours. A simple text or email that says, “Thanks for joining us at happy hour yesterday! Hope you enjoyed the Moscow Mule. If you fancy stopping by this weekend, our kitchen just created an amazing new bar snack menu.” This feels personal, not promotional.
Mention what’s coming up that week:
Build a habit of teasing next week’s happy hour deal in your stories or newsletters. Run a weekly happy hour email that highlights what’s special about next week’s offerings. “This Tuesday’s happy hour features our new summer spritz menu and live acoustic music.” Give them a specific reason to return on a specific day.
Segment visitors based on what they ordered:
Wine drinkers should receive different follow-up messages than craft beer enthusiasts. “We noticed you enjoyed our natural wines on Thursday. We just got a limited shipment of that small-batch Syrah you might like.”.
Use social media:
Post staff picks, behind-the-scenes peeks, or funny bar moments that give your pub personality. When you tag happy hour guests (with permission), they feel recognised and special. Their friends also see their connection to your venue.
Personality matters more than polish:
Bars that communicate with genuine humor and character stand out from corporate-feeling competitors. Let your bar’s unique vibe shine through in all communications. And, if you spot guests tagging you, reshare the post and thank them publicly. This doesn’t just keep you relevant; it shows you care.
Owner’s Tip
Schedule a weekly happy hour preview post every Monday on Instagram or SMS to re-engage last week’s guests.
Staying in touch builds familiarity, but real loyalty comes from a human connection. That’s where your team comes in.
Step 4: Build Personal Connection Through Staff
People return to places where they feel recognised.
Drinks bring people in, and staff keep them coming back. Guests return to places where they feel recognised and appreciated, not just served.
Let’s get practical:
Train your team to remember faces and drinks:
Teach them to use names. If a guest says their name, remember it. Better yet, write it down in a quiet moment.
Bar team shoutouts create an instant connection. When a returning happy hour guest arrives, I’d tell my team to call out: “Hey everyone, James is back!” Nothing makes someone feel more special than public recognition.
Develop simple memory systems:
Keep a shared notebook or digital file with notes about repeat guests, where bartenders would jot down memorable guests with brief details: “John – bearded guy, drinks IPA, works in finance, mentioned skiing trip” or “Jack – Loves Pinot, hates loud music, comes Tuesdays.” These notes got reviewed before the next shift.
Encourage real conversations:
Genuine conversation matters more than drink-making skills. Teach staff to develop conversation starters beyond “How’s your day?” or “How’s your drink?”. Instead, try “Did you enjoy that Negroni last time? We just got a new vermouth I think you’d like.” or “You went for the spicy margarita…brave choice!”.
Create standardised handover procedures between shifts:
Nothing feels worse than being recognised by the afternoon team but treated like a stranger by the evening staff. Notes in your POS or a quick team huddle can fix this.
Make personalised recommendations:
Train bartenders to make personalised recommendations based on previous orders. “Since you enjoyed our mezcal last time, I think you’d love this small-batch tequila we just got in.”
Technology can help:
Many POS systems can flag returning customers or add notes to their profiles. “Welcome back, Sarah! Gin and tonic with cucumber, right?” This kind of recognition feels like magic to guests.
Celebrate small wins:
Praise your team when they connect with a guest who comes back the following week. Incentivize staff who successfully convert happy hour visitors to regulars.
Owner’s Tip
Reward staff who get mentioned by name in reviews. It means they’re making a connection.
And when the connection is built, you can introduce routines that lock in repeat behaviour.
Step 5: Establish Rituals That Stick
Loyalty often grows from habit. So give guests a reason to come regularly.
People love routines. If you give guests something to look forward to, they’ll build their plans around you. Rituals create community.
Try these ideas:
Themed nights:
Weekly themes create anticipation and regular visit patterns. “Martini Mondays” or “Flight Club Fridays” give people a specific day to mark on their calendars.
VIP perks:
A “regular’s hour” just before happy hour starts gives early birds a VIP feeling. “Happy hour starts at 5, but regulars can start at 4:30.” This costs you nothing but creates strong loyalty.
Time-limited exclusives:
Offer Early access to new cocktails during happy hour only: “Our barrel-aged Manhattan is only available between 5-7 pm on Wednesdays.” This creates a compelling reason to visit during specific times. “Secret menu” items available only to returning customers create insider status. “Since you’ve been there a few times, would you like to see our special reserve menu?” Everyone loves being an insider.
Implement a “Bartender’s Table” experience:
Reserve one prime spot at your bar for returning happy hour customers who’ve graduated to regular status. These customers receive special treatment, taste new products, and direct interaction with your best bartenders.
These rituals turn your pub into a place people don’t want to miss.
Owner’s Tip
Pilot one weekly ritual for a month, like a Thursday quiz or tasting flight, then scale what works.
Once you’ve built a habit, your final step is to turn loyal guests into brand advocates.
Step 6: Empower Regulars to Spread the Word
Loyal guests become your best marketing team.
Your regulars already like you. Now help them bring their friends. Word-of-mouth is more trusted than any ad.
Make your fans your marketers:
Offer rewards for referrals:
Offer clear perks for referrals, such as free drinks, priority bookings, or sneak peeks. “Bring a mate, get a sharer cocktail free” is simple and effective. Make the reward immediate and visible, not a distant promise.
Feature guests on your socials:
Feature guests on your social feed with a fun “Happy Hour Hero of the Month” shoutout. People love recognition; their friends will see their association with your venue. Make sure to get permission first!
Build a list for early invites to special nights:
Create a “Friends of the Bar” WhatsApp or email list for priority event invitations to special nights.. This exclusive communication channel makes people feel like true insiders.
Develop “Member Nights”:
Where regulars can bring guests at happy hour prices, even during regular hours, this introduces new potential customers to your venue with a trusted advocate singing your praises.
Regular’s Wall of Fame:
Implement a “Regular’s Wall of Fame” featuring photos or signatures of loyal patrons. Physical recognition in your space creates strong emotional connections.
Owner’s Tip
Print mini referral cards or digital codes regulars can share. Track redemptions to see who’s driving traffic.
Loyalty is one part of the puzzle, for the full happy hour playbook, see Happy Hour Done Right.
Let’s bring it all together with a simple summary:
Every guest is a potential regular. You just need a plan to get them there.
Start with the experience. Give them a reason to return. Stay present, build a bond, and create rituals that keep them coming back. Once you’ve done that, let them spread the word.
- Nail the First Experience: Warm greetings, clean setup, and manager visibility are all key to a great first impression.
- Create a Reason to Return: Hand out bounce-back offers and offer limited-time perks to draw them in again.
- Stay Present When They’re Gone: Use email, SMS, and social media to keep the connection alive and remind them of what’s next.
- Build Personal Connection Through Staff: Encourage name use, conversations, and shared knowledge among your team.
- Establish Rituals: Weekly themes or exclusive events give guests something to return for.
- Empower Your Regulars: Turn happy hour fans into advocates with perks and recognition.
Each step builds on the last. Start small, stay consistent, and track what sticks. Treat every happy hour guest as a future regular, because with the right strategy, they will be.
Your Next Move: Try these six steps over the next 6 weeks and see how many happy hour guests become your biggest advocates.
FAQs
-
1. How do we prevent our regular customers from shifting their visits to happy hour?
This is a common concern! The best approach is to design your happy hour to attract a somewhat different customer base than your regular business. Target customers who might not otherwise visit, such as early evening office workers, if your usual crowd arrives later. You can also create happy hour specials that differ from what your regulars typically order, reducing the incentive for them to shift their visits.
-
2. How do I prevent customers from only coming for the discounts?
Structure promotions to encourage higher spending through techniques like minimum orders, food pairings, or escalating discounts. For example, our "Flight Night" happy hour required purchasing a tasting flight to access special pricing, ensuring minimum spending. Training staff to effectively upsell beyond happy hour items is also crucial. A well-designed happy hour naturally leads customers to explore your regular offerings.
Group
